On the morning of Saturday, Oct. 24, about 40 Montvale residents had coffee outside one of the working greenhouses on the old DePiero farm. They asked Mayor Michael Ghassali about traffic, the planned Veolia water tower, a Trader Joe's and the deer. Pascack Press reported that pumpkins lined the refurbished farmstand at 56 Craig Road, and the mayor told residents to stop in for fresh produce, pastries, pies, and hot and cold drinks.
Fourteen months earlier, the stand on this land had closed for good. DePiero's Farm Stand & Greenhouses had its last day on Aug. 28, 2025, after operating since 1924, and News 12 reported that the owners pointed to rising costs. The land now holds a community garden, a 20-year farm lease and a stand run by two neighbors, because of a borough vote taken more than two years before that last day.
Montvale budgeted for the farm in 2023
The money was in place long before anyone said goodbye to the stand. On May 30, 2023, the Mayor and Council adopted a bond ordinance that set aside $5.15 million to buy the property. It authorized $4.9 million in bonds or notes and covered the remaining $250,000 as a down payment from money in budgets the borough had already adopted.
The purchase itself came the next summer. Council minutes from July 2024 expected a closing on July 31, and Pascack Press dates the acquisition of the 8.4-acre DePiero Farm property to August 2024. At the time, borough officials said the preserved farmland would be used for agriculture and community purposes, including a community garden and a farmstand.
Counting from that first vote, the land was public farmland for its entire last stretch as DePiero's. When the family stand closed in August 2025, the borough's plan for the next chapter was already written down.
Three bids and a 20-year lease
Owning a farm doesn't give a town a farmer, so in fall 2025 Montvale put the operation out to bid. Three bids came in for an annual lease of the 8.4 acres, and each one had to rise 2% a year. D'Agostino Landscaping of West Nyack, N.Y., bid $43,200 a year. The other two bids were $12,000 a year each, and one of them came from Matthew Epstein and Matthew Worgul, two Montvale residents bidding together.
The Borough Council gave the lease to D'Agostino on Oct. 28, 2025, and a Superior Court decision on Dec. 22, 2025, left that award in place. Pascack Press reported that the court found D'Agostino had a farming and business location within 10 miles of Montvale and had worked with DePiero Farm for 10 years before it bid.
The dollar figures put the purchase price in context. Borough Attorney David Lafferty put the gap between the top bid and the $12,000 bids at about $750,000 over the 20-year term. By our own math, $43,200 a year growing 2% annually adds up to roughly $1.05 million in rent over the 20 years of the lease. That is about a fifth of the $5.15 million the borough set aside in 2023, and it comes in while the land stays in farming.
Pascack Press quoted Mayor Ghassali after the decision: "What matters most moving forward is that this land remains a working farm while also creating more open green space for our residents, and a full community garden to enjoy."
156 Summit Avenue is where residents grow their own
Most of the property is leased to D'Agostino for agriculture. One piece of it belongs to anyone in town with a trowel. Montvale's community garden officially opened on May 31, 2026, at 156 Summit Ave., just east of Craig Road.
The first season had 40 raised beds. Each one is galvanized steel, 8 feet by 4 feet, filled with certified clean soil for vegetables and flowers, and water is available across the site. Volunteers spent months putting in the beds, fencing and gravel paths. Environmental Commission Chair Robert Hanrahan told Pascack Press that the commission had been trying to get a community garden in Montvale for at least a decade. Buying the farm gave that decade-old idea a place to go.
Students from Pascack Hills High School were expected to tend one bed and give the produce to local food pantries. The garden is also set to grow. In June, Hanrahan described a plan to reach 100 plots "within a year": 10 more beds at the current site and a second garden area with 50 more. He also described a pavilion for shade and gatherings planned for next year. Officials said a walking path would connect the garden to the farmstand. If you missed out on a bed this year, the plan as described in June would more than double the number of plots by next growing season.
56 Craig Road is where two neighbors sell pies
Epstein and Worgul bid $12,000 a year to run the whole farm, and the lease went to a bid more than three times larger. They now run The Montvale Farmstand under a lease from D'Agostino Landscaping, the company that won.
In June, Pascack Press described the two of them as residents getting ready to open a stand near the garden, with locally grown produce, coffee and pastries. By the late-October forum, the stand at 56 Craig Road had been refurbished and was being decorated for the season. Its counter carried produce, pastries, pies, and hot and cold drinks, and the morning coffee with the mayor was held next to greenhouses that are still in use. Council members Dieter Koelling, Chris Roche, Theresa Cudequest and Douglas Arendacs joined Ghassali, and the two farmstand operators were there too.
When the concept was first announced in March, it was billed as a "Community Forward Farm," with a traditional farmstand, weekend farmers markets, classes and activities built around local agriculture, Boozy Burbs reported. The same item listed the farmstand's Instagram account, @montvalefarmstand.
Two addresses on one farm
Montvale residents used to have one address for the farm: the DePiero's stand. The same 8.4 acres now have two. The garden entrance is at 156 Summit Avenue and the farmstand is around the corner at 56 Craig Road. The rest of the acreage is D'Agostino's to farm under its lease.
If you're coming from Market Street after a Wegmans run or dinner, you're a short drive from both. The name is the only connection between the farm and The Shoppes at DePiero's Farm, so the farm and the shopping center are worth keeping straight when you give directions to out-of-town family this week. Our Montvale neighborhood guide has more on the rest of town.
At Team Deutsch, we follow what Montvale decides to do with its open land, including the farm on Summit Avenue and Craig Road. If you own a home in Montvale and want to know what it's worth today, start with our home value request.